Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Umair's avatar

unfortunately we are not the same club any more Score!

Club owners publicly praised clubs like Brighton and for anyone smart enough it was clear to see that they wanted us to be a beefier version of Brighton. The profits / returns come first and if along the way we pick up some wins that's great.

Iv been saying this for a long time that ambition is not spending money like drunken sailors on alot of young players. They are just building assets which can be flipped for a higher fee if possible down the line and more assets can be bought. Its a player trading exercise ever since Clearlake walked in.

Winning teams have experience, leadership and quality. Their model does not value experience or leadership. The quality is there in just a couple of positions. They wont change their model unless they face failure for multiple seasons... and thats unfortunate

Expand full comment
Jeff Whelpley's avatar

I was re-watching Moneyball the other day and I realized that some people in the Chelsea organization right now think they are Billy Beane and/or Peter Brand. They think they know something the rest of the industry doesn't. It may seem to everyone on the outside that Chelsea need another striker and a top class goalie, but from the point of view of the data they are looking at, they are doing just fine.

There is, of course, many problems with this that I shouldn't have to point out but I will focus on just one.

Billy Bean run Oakland A's World Series Championships: zero

They have literally won nothing of consequence. Oh, they are super competitive and they get close every season with exciting games from time to time. But the last time they actually won the World Series is 36 years ago (well before Billy Beane took over)!

Really what it comes down to is your objectives. Is your objective to actually win a trophy or do you just want to be good enough to be successful as a business? Sure, you can want to have both but at the end of the day one of the two things has to be a slightly higher priority than the other and that has a dramatic impact on how you run the organization.

IMO it is super clear that while the owners would love to win trophies, it is not in reality their top priority. I certainly don't think they should abandon their principles of running a sustainable business. I just think they need to balance their Moneyball mentality with the need to build the right culture at Chelsea that includes winning trophies every single season (i.e. not constantly building toward some super team that will likely never happen in 3 to 5 seasons).

Expand full comment
12 more comments...

No posts